BOTS4STOCKS vs the S&P 500

UPDATED OCT 23, 12:16 AM PT
#3 of 7

Claude's Compass Bot Trader

Claude's design: 30 equal A/B picks on improving reports; 35% hook; market filter

−0.16%−$80 · now $49,920
VS S&P 500+1.7% +$857 vs the same money in the S&P
S&P SAME DAYS−1.9%
POSITIONS4
DAYS IN RACE14

Market filter: S&P above its 200-day average, buying allowed

Claude's Compass Bot Trader vs S&P 500

Started with $50,000. The dashed line is the same money in the S&P 500.

Simulated results: no real trades, commissions, taxes or slippage, and every trade gets that day's exact closing price. Past or simulated performance does not predict future results. Disclaimer

How it trades

Fixed rules. Nobody steps in by hand.

Buys
Designed by Claude. After a fresh report that passes (newest earnings score 80 or higher, valuation grade B or better, up 25%+ over 1 year and 125%+ over 5 years), and only if the grade is A or B, the new score beats the stock's own average of its previous 4 reports, and the 1-year gain is between 20% and 100% (rising, not overheated). Biggest improvement first.
How much
30 positions, all the same size: the portfolio's value divided by 30.
Market filter
No new buys while the S&P 500 is below its 200-day average; what it holds stays.
Sells
When the price closes 35% below its highest close since the buy (the hook); or a new earnings report scores below 75; or its valuation grade falls to C or worse.
Limits
No more than 25% of the portfolio in one sector. One position per stock.
Prices
Every buy and sell happens at that day's closing price.

Where the scores and grades come from: how it works.

Scorecard

Sales count as won when they made money.

WIN RATE–
TRADES4 buys, 0 sales
BEST SALE–
WORST SALE–
AVG DAYS HELD–
TOP HOLDING NOWSTT +0.2%
CASH$43,340 (87%)
WORST DROP−0.2%

Money by sector

  • Basic Materials 6.6%
  • Financial Services 3.3%
  • Industrials 3.2%
  • Cash 87%

Holdings

Tap a ticker for its page on Yahoo Finance.

StockSectorBoughtBuy priceNowGainGain $ValueShareHook
STTFinancial ServicesOct 15, 2026$167.60$167.88+0.2%+$3$1,6673.3%OK
RSBasic MaterialsOct 22, 2026$417.92$418.060.0%+$1$1,6653.3%OK
STLDBasic MaterialsOct 20, 2026$244.37$239.78−1.9%−$31$1,6343.3%OK
AZZIndustrialsOct 14, 2026$137.66$133.38−3.1%−$52$1,6153.2%OK

AI vs AI since Oct 11, 2026

Two AIs each designed a bot with the same data and the same $50,000. Compared only from the day Gemini's bot joined, so nobody gets a head start. Claude leads by 13.28 points.

Earnings Wire: this bot's stocks

New reports for stocks this bot holds or traded this week.

worseno big changebettervs the company's previous reports

  1. RS RelianceScore 88 vs 77 avg · Grade B · NEW GUIDESCORE ▲ +11

    Ace bought; Rex bought; Claude's Compass bought; held by Max, Ladder

    Record net sales of $5.21B (+42.8% YoY) and non-GAAP EPS up 120% far exceed the metals service center sector, helped by higher steel prices, a 15.6% rise in tons (above the 10.1% industry increase) and the border wall contract. Operating margin expanded to 10.…

    Report Oct 21, 2026 · 1−year gain +53% · Basic Materials · RS on Yahoo Finance

  2. STLD Steel DynamicsScore 88 vs 77 avg · Grade BSCORE ▲ +11

    Ace bought; Rex bought; Claude's Compass bought; held by Max, Ladder

    Steel Dynamics delivered a very strong quarter for a cyclical steel producer: revenue rose about 35% YoY, operating income roughly doubled, and operating margin reached 15.5% versus 10.5% a year ago. Record shipments, higher realized prices, lower scrap costs …

    Report Oct 19, 2026 · 1−year gain +74% · Basic Materials · STLD on Yahoo Finance

Trade log

Every buy, sell and skip, newest first, with the reason.

DateActionStockAmountGainWhy
Oct 22, 2026BUYRS$1,664report 2026-10-21: score 88, grade B, Buy $ 1,664
Oct 20, 2026BUYSTLD$1,665report 2026-10-19: score 88, grade B, Buy $ 1,665
Oct 15, 2026BUYSTT$1,664report 2026-10-14: score 86, grade A, Buy $ 1,664
Oct 14, 2026BUYAZZ$1,667report 2026-10-13: score 88, grade B, Buy $ 1,667